Systems and methods for calibration feedback for additive manufacturing

ABSTRACT

A camera assembly is employed in additive manufacturing to improve the fidelity of a printed object. The camera may scan the surface of a build plate of a 3D printer and an object as it is being printed to generate image data. The image data is processed to detect errors in the build plate or printed object. The printer compensates for the detected errors, which can including modifying the printer configuration and/or modifying the instructions for printing a given object. Using the updated configuration, subsequent objects may then be printed, under a corrected process, to produce an object with fidelity to an original object model.

BACKGROUND

Metal injection molding (MIM) is a metalworking process useful increating a variety of metal objects. A mixture of powdered metal andbinder (e.g., a polymer such as polypropylene) forms a “feedstock”capable of being molded, at a high temperature, into the shape of adesired object. The initial molded part, also referred to as a “greenpart,” then undergoes a debinding process to remove the binder, followedby a sintering process. During sintering, the part is brought to atemperature near the melting point of the powdered metal, whichevaporates any remaining binder and forming the metal powder into asolid mass, thereby producing the desired object.

Additive manufacturing, also referred to as 3D printing, includes avariety of techniques for manufacturing a three-dimensional object viaan automated process of forming successive layers of the object. 3Dprinters may utilize a feedstock comparable to that used in MIM, therebycreating a green part without the need for a mold. The green part maythen undergo comparable debinding and sintering processes to produce theobject.

SUMMARY

Example embodiments provide for fabricating objects through additivemanufacturing. In one embodiment, a surface of a build plate of a 3Dprinter is scanned to generate an image of the build plate. A depth mapof the build plate is then generated, the depth map indicatingdeviations from a defined plane at a surface of the build plate. A printconfiguration may then be updated based on the depth map, where theprint configuration includes values enabling compensation for thedeviations during printing of an object. Using the updatedconfiguration, an object may then be printed, under a compensatedprocess, to produce an object with fidelity to an original object model.

In further embodiments, scanning the surface of the build plate mayinclude capturing at one or more photographs of the build plate via acamera coupled to a print head. The photographs may be stitched togetherto generate a single image of the build plate. The camera and print headmay be moved through distinct locations above the build plate to capturethe photographs. A tool path may be generated for a print head based onthe print configuration, wherein printing the object includescontrolling the print head to print the object based on the tool path. Acalibration object (e.g., a pattern printed on the build plate) may bescanned in addition to the build plate, and the print configuration maybe updated based on the calibration object. In particular, the geometryof a representation of the object may be generated based on deviationsbetween the calibration object and the depiction of the calibrationobject. Further, a positional error vectormap may be produced based onthe depiction of the at least one calibration object.

In still further embodiments, material deposition flow rate may becontrolled, as a function of tool location and the print configuration,to compensate for the deviations. Updating the print configuration mayinclude updating a configuration of a motion system of the 3D printer,and may incorporate an offset plane defining a location for printing anobject layer, the offset plane enabling compensation for the deviationsduring printing of an object. The offset plane may further enablecompensation for deviations between the defined plane and a motion planeoccupied by a print head of the 3D printer. The update to the printconfiguration may include an update to the firmware of the 3D printer.Embodiments may further include generating print parameters based on aninitial model of the object and the depth map, the print parametersdefining geometry of the object with offsets to the initial model, theoffsets corresponding to the deviations.

Further embodiments may include a method of printing an object followingfabrication and printing of an initial object. A first object may beprinted at a 3D printer based on an initial model of an object. Aplurality of layers of the first object may be scanned concurrently withthe printing to generate image data of the first object. Deviations maybe detected between the image data and the initial model. A printconfiguration of the 3D printer may be updated based on the image data,where the print configuration defines operation of the 3D printer andincluding values enabling compensation for the deviations duringprinting of an object. A second object may then be printed under theupdated print configuration.

Still further embodiments may include a method of printing and scanningsuccessive objects. A first object may be printed at a 3D printer basedon an initial model of an object. A plurality of layers of the firstobject may be scanned concurrently with the printing to generate imagedata of the first object. Deviations may be detected between the imagedata and the initial model. Print parameters of the object may beupdated based on an initial model of the object and the image data, theprint parameters defining geometry of the object with offsets to theinitial model based on the detected deviations. A second object may thenbe printed based on the updated print parameters.

In yet further embodiments, photographs of a plurality ofcross-sectional layers of the first object may be captured concurrentlywith the printing of the first object, the image data incorporating thephotographs. Updating the print parameters may include modifying thegeometry of a representation of the object based on deviations betweenthe initial model and the photographs of the plurality ofcross-sectional layers of the first object. Updating the printparameters may also include generating a correction tool path for aprint head based on the detected deviations. The second object may beprinted by controlling the print head based on the correction tool path.Further, during printing of the second object, material deposition flowrate may be controlled as a function of tool location and the correctiontool path. The correction tool path may also be implemented to correctthe printing of the first object, by printing an initial portion of theobject, and then printing a successive portion of the first objectaccording to the correction tool path. Further updating the printparameters may include generating a correction model of the object, thecorrection model defining geometry of the object with offsets to theinitial model based on the detected deviations.

Yet further embodiments of the object may include a system for printingobjects. The system may include a build chamber, a print head, a camera,and a controller. The print head may be configured to print objectswithin the build chamber, and the camera may be mounted to the print andconfigured to capture images within the build chamber. The controllermay be configured to 1) control the camera to scan a plurality of layersof a first object concurrently with printing of the first object togenerate image data of the first object, 2) detecting deviations betweenthe image data and an initial model of the object, and 3) update printparameters of the object based on an initial model of the object and theimage data, the print parameters defining geometry of the object withoffsets to the initial model based on the detected deviations.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The foregoing will be apparent from the following more particulardescription of example embodiments of the invention, as illustrated inthe accompanying drawings in which like reference characters refer tothe same parts throughout the different views. The drawings are notnecessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illustratingembodiments of the present invention.

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an additive manufacturing system for usewith composites.

FIG. 2 is a flow chart of a method for printing with composites.

FIG. 3 illustrates an additive manufacturing system for use with metalinjection molding materials.

FIG. 4 illustrates a stereolithography process using a metallic powderand an ultraviolet-curable binder.

FIG. 5 illustrates a laser binding process for using powder metallurgymaterials.

FIGS. 6A-B illustrate camera and print head assembly within a buildchamber in one embodiment.

FIGS. 7A-B illustrate a camera and print head assembly during a scan ofa build plate.

FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of a process of scanning and a surface of abuild plate and calibrating a printer based on the scan.

FIGS. 9A-B illustrate a printed calibration pattern in one embodiment.

FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of a process of calibrating a printer based ona printed calibration pattern.

FIGS. 11A-B illustrate a camera and print head assembly during a printof portions of an object.

FIGS. 12A-B are block diagrams of error data in one embodiment.

FIG. 13 is a block diagram illustrating generation of print parametersby a control system in one embodiment.

FIG. 14 is a flow diagram of a process of scanning a printed object andcalibrating print parameters based on the scan.

FIG. 15 is a flow diagram of a process of modifying print parameters foran object undergoing a print based on a simultaneous scan of the object.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an additive manufacturing system for usewith composites. The additive manufacturing system may include athree-dimensional printer 100 (or simply printer 100) that depositsmetal using fused filament fabrication. Fused filament fabrication iswell known in the art, and may be usefully employed for additivemanufacturing with suitable adaptations to accommodate the forces,temperatures and other environmental requirements typical of themetallic injection molding materials described herein. In general, theprinter 100 may include a build material 102 that is propelled by adrive train 104 and heated to a workable state by a liquefaction system106, and then dispensed through one or more nozzles 110. By concurrentlycontrolling robotic system 108 to position the nozzle(s) along anextrusion path, an object 112 may be fabricated on a build plate 114within a build chamber 116. In general, a control system 118 managesoperation of the printer 100 to fabricate the object 112 according to athree-dimensional model using a fused filament fabrication process orthe like.

A variety of commercially available compositions have been engineeredfor metal injection molding (“MIM”). These highly engineered materialscan also be adapted for use as a build material 102 in printingtechniques such as fused filament fabrication. For example, MIMfeedstock materials, when suitably shaped, may be usefully extrudedthrough nozzles typical of commercially available FFF machines, and aregenerally flowable or extrudable within typical operating temperatures(e.g., 160-250 degrees Celsius) of such machines. This temperature rangemay depend on the binder—e.g., some binders achieve appropriateviscosities at about 205 degrees Celsius, while others achieveappropriate viscosities at lower temperatures such as about 160-180 Cdegrees Celsius. One of ordinary skill will recognize that these ranges(and all ranges listed herein) are provided by way of example and not oflimitation. Further, while there are no formal limits on the dimensionsfor powder metallurgy materials, parts with dimensions of around 100millimeters on each side have been demonstrated to perform well for FFFfabrication of net shape green bodies. Any smaller dimensions may beusefully employed, and larger dimensions may also be employed providedthey are consistent with processing dimensions such as the printresolution and the extrusion orifice diameter. For example,implementations target about a 0.300 μm diameter extrusion, and the MIMmetal powder may typically be about 1˜22 μm diameter, although nanosized powders can be used. The term metal injection molding material, asused herein, may include any such engineered materials, as well as otherfine powder bases such as ceramics in a similar binder suitable forinjection molding. Thus, where the term metal injection molding or thecommonly used abbreviation, MIM, is used, the term may include injectionmolding materials using powders other than, or in addition to, metalsand, thus, may include ceramics. Also, any reference to “MIM materials,”“powder metallurgy materials,” “MIM feedstocks,” or the like maygenerally refer to metal powder and/or ceramic powder mixed with one ormore binding materials, e.g., a backbone binder that holds everythingtogether and a bulk binder that carries the metal and backbone intoposition within a mold or print. Other material systems may be suitablefor fabricating metal parts using fabrication techniques such asstereolithography or binder jetting, some of which are discussed ingreater detail below. Such fabrication techniques may, in someapplications, be identical to techniques for fabricating parts fromceramic material.

In general, fabrication of such materials may proceed as with aconventional FFF process, except that after the net shape is created,the green part may be optionally machined or finished while in a moreeasily workable state, and then debound and sintered into a final, denseobject using any of the methods common in the art for MIM materials. Thefinal object, as described above, may include a metal, a metal alloy, aceramic, or another suitable combination of materials.

The build material 102 may be fed from a carrier 103 configured todispense the build material to the three-dimensional printer either in acontinuous (e.g., wire) or discrete (e.g., billet) form. The buildmaterial 102 may for example be supplied in discrete units one by one asbillets or the like into an intermediate chamber for delivery into thebuild chamber 118 and subsequent melt and deposition. In another aspect,the carrier 103 may include a spool or cartridge containing the buildmaterial 102 in a wire form. Where a vacuum or other controlledenvironment is desired, the wire may be fed through a vacuum gasket intothe build chamber 118 in a continuous fashion, however, typical MIMmaterials can be heated to a workable plastic state under normalatmospheric conditions, except perhaps for filtering or the like toremove particles from the build chamber 116. Thus in one aspect, thereis described herein an apparatus including a MIM build material formedinto a wire, the build material including an engineered composite ofmetal powder and a polymeric binder or the like, wherein the carrier 103is configured to dispense the build material in a continuous feed to athree-dimensional printer. For environmentally sensitive materials, thecarrier 103 may provide a vacuum environment for the build material 102that can be directly or indirectly coupled to the vacuum environment ofthe build chamber 118. More generally, the build chamber 118 (and thecarrier 103) may maintain any suitably inert environment for handling ofthe build material 102, such as a vacuum, and oxygen-depletedenvironment, an inert gas environment, or some gas or combination ofgasses that are not reactive with the build material 102 where suchconditions are necessary or beneficial during three-dimensionalfabrication.

A drive train 104 may include any suitable gears, compression pistons,or the like for continuous or indexed feeding of the build material 116into the liquefaction system 106. In one aspect, the drive train 104 mayinclude gear shaped to mesh with corresponding features in the buildmaterial such as ridges, notches, or other positive or negative detents.In another aspect, the drive train 104 may use heated gears or screwmechanisms to deform and engage with the build material. Thus there isdescribed in one aspect a printer for a fused filament fabricationprocess that heats a build material to a working temperature, and thatheats a gear that engages with, deforms, and drives the composite in afeed path. A screw feed may also or instead be used.

For more brittle MIM materials, a fine-toothed drive gear of a materialsuch as a hard resin or plastic may be used to grip the material withoutexcessive cutting or stress concentrations that might otherwise crack,strip, or otherwise compromise the build material.

In another aspect, the drive train 104 may use bellows, or any othercollapsible or telescoping press to drive rods, billets, or similarunits of build material into the liquefaction system 106. Similarly, apiezoelectric or linear stepper drive may be used to advance a unit ofbuild media in a non-continuous, stepped method with discrete,high-powered mechanical increments. In another aspect, the drive train104 may include multiple stages. In a first stage, the drive train 104may heat the composite material and form threads or other features thatcan supply positive gripping traction into the material. In the nextstage, a gear or the like matching these features can be used to advancethe build material along the feed path. A collet feed may be used (e.g.,similar to those on a mechanical pencil). A soft wheel or belt drive mayalso or instead be used. In an aspect, a shape forming wheel drive maybe used to ensure accuracy of size and thus the build. More generally,the drive train 104 may include any mechanism or combination ofmechanisms used to advance build material 102 for deposition in athree-dimensional fabrication process.

The liquefaction system 106 may be any liquefaction system configured toheat the composite to a working temperature in a range suitable forextrusion in a fused filament fabrication process. Any number of heatingtechniques may be used. In one aspect, electrical techniques such asinductive or resistive heating may be usefully applied to liquefy thebuild material 102. This may, for example include inductively orresistively heating a chamber around the build material 102 to atemperature at or near the glass transition temperature of the buildmaterial 102, or some other temperature where the binder or other matrixbecomes workable, extrudable, or flowable for deposition as describedherein. Where the contemplated build materials are sufficientlyconductive, they may be directly heated through contact methods (e.g.,resistive heating with applied current) or non-contact methods (e.g.,induction heating using an external electromagnet to drive eddy currentswithin the material). The choice of additives may further beadvantageously selected to provide bulk electrical characteristics(e.g., conductance/resistivity) to improve heating. When directlyheating the build material 102, it may be useful to model the shape andsize of the build material 102 in order to better controlelectrically-induced heating. This may include estimates or actualmeasurements of shape, size, mass, etc.

In the above context, “liquefaction” does not require completeliquefaction. That is, the media to be used in printing may be in amulti-phase state, and/or form a paste or the like having highly viscousand/or non-Newtonian fluid properties. Thus the liquefaction system 106described herein may include, more generally, any system that places abuild material 102 in condition for use in fabrication as describedherein.

In order to facilitate resistive heating of the build material 102, oneor more contact pads, probes or the like may be positioned within thefeed path for the material in order to provide locations for forming acircuit through the material at the appropriate location(s). In order tofacilitate induction heating, one or more electromagnets may bepositioned at suitable locations adjacent to the feed path and operated,e.g., by the control system 118, to heat the build material internallythrough the creation of eddy currents. In one aspect, both of thesetechniques may be used concurrently to achieve a more tightly controlledor more evenly distributed electrical heating within the build material.The printer 100 may also be instrumented to monitor the resultingheating in a variety of ways. For example, the printer 100 may monitorpower delivered to the inductive or resistive circuits. The printer 100may also or instead measure temperature of the build material 102 orsurrounding environment at any number of locations. In another aspect,the temperature of the build material 102 may be inferred by measuring,e.g., the amount of force required to drive the build material 102through a nozzle 110 or other portion of the feed path, which may beused as a proxy for the viscosity of the build material 102. Moregenerally, any techniques suitable for measuring temperature orviscosity of the build material 102 and responsively controlling appliedelectrical energy may be used to control liquefaction for a fabricationprocess using composites as described herein.

The liquefaction system 106 may also or instead include any otherheating systems suitable for applying heat to the build material 102 toa suitable temperature for extrusion. This may, for example includetechniques for locally or globally augmenting heating using, e.g.,chemical heating, combustion, ultrasound heating, laser heating,electron beam heating or other optical or mechanical heating techniquesand so forth.

The liquefaction system 106 may include a shearing engine. The shearingengine may create shear within the composite as it is heated in order tomaintain a mixture of the metallic base and a binder or other matrix, orto maintain a mixture of various materials in a paste or other buildmaterial. A variety of techniques may be employed by the shearingengine. In one aspect, the bulk media may be axially rotated as it isfed along the feed path into the liquefaction system 106. In anotheraspect, one or more ultrasonic transducers may be used to introduceshear within the heated material. Similarly, a screw, post, arm, orother physical element may be placed within the heated media and rotatedor otherwise actuated to mix the heated material. In an aspect, bulkbuild material may include individual pellets, rods, or coils (e.g., ofconsistent size) and fed into a screw, a plunger, a rod extruder, or thelike. For example, a coiled build material can be uncoiled with a heatersystem including a heated box, heated tube, or heater from the printhead. Also, a direct feed with no heat that feeds right into the printhead is also possible.

The robotic system 108 may include a robotic system configured tothree-dimensionally position the nozzle 110 within the working volume115 of the build chamber 116. This may, for example, include any roboticcomponents or systems suitable for positioning the nozzle 110 relativeto the build plate 114 while depositing the composite in a pattern tofabricate the object 112. A variety of robotics systems are known in theart and suitable for use as the robotic system 108 described herein. Forexample, the robotics may include a Cartesian or xy-z robotics systememploying a number of linear controls to move independently in thex-axis, the y-axis, and the z-axis within the build chamber 116. Deltarobots may also or instead be usefully employed, which can, if properlyconfigured, provide significant advantages in terms of speed andstiffness, as well as offering the design convenience of fixed motors ordrive elements. Other configurations such as double or triple deltarobots can increase range of motion using multiple linkages. Moregenerally, any robotics suitable for controlled positioning of thenozzle 110 relative to the build plate 114, especially within a vacuumor similar environment, may be usefully employed including any mechanismor combination of mechanisms suitable for actuation, manipulation,locomotion and the like within the build chamber 116.

The nozzle(s) 110 may include one or more nozzles for dispensing thebuild material 102 that has been propelled with the drive train 104 andheated with the liquefaction system 106 to a suitable workingtemperature. In a multiphase extrusion this may include a workingtemperature above the melting temperature of the metallic base of thecomposite, or more specifically between a first temperature at which themetallic base melts and the second temperature (above the firsttemperature) at which a second phase of the composite remains inert.

The nozzles 110 may, for example, be used to dispense different types ofmaterial so that, for example, one nozzle 110 dispenses a compositebuild material while another nozzle 110 dispenses a support material inorder to support bridges, overhangs, and other structural features ofthe object 112 that would otherwise violate design rules for fabricationwith the composite build material. In another aspect, one of the nozzles110 may deposit a different type of material, such as a thermallycompatible polymer or a metal or polymer loaded with fibers of one ormore materials to increase tensile strength or otherwise improvemechanical properties of the resulting object 112. In an aspect, twotypes of supports may be used—(1) build supports and (2) sintersupports—e.g., using different materials printed into the same part toachieve these supports, or to create a distinguishing junction betweenthese supports and the part.

The nozzle 110 may preferably be formed of a material or combination ofmaterials with suitable mechanical and thermal properties. For example,the nozzle 110 will preferably not degrade at the temperatures whereinthe composite material is to be dispensed, or due to the passage ofmetallic particles through a dispensing orifice therein. While nozzlesfor traditional polymer-based fused filament fabrication may be madefrom brass or aluminum alloys, a nozzle that dispenses metal particlesmay be formed of harder materials, or materials compatible with moreelevated working temperatures such as a high carbon steel that ishardened and tempered. Other materials such as a refractory metal (e.g.molybdenum, tungsten) or refractory ceramic (e.g. mullite, corundum,magnesia) may also or instead be employed. In some instances, aluminumnozzles may instead be used for MIM extrusion of certain MIM materials.In another aspect, a softer thermally conductive material with a hard,wear-resistant coating may be used, such as copper with a hard nickelplating.

In one aspect, the nozzle 110 may include one or more ultrasoundtransducers 130 as described herein. Ultrasound may be usefully appliedfor a variety of purposes in this context. In one aspect, the ultrasoundenergy may facilitate extrusion by mitigating clogging by reducingadhesion of a build material to an interior surface of the nozzle 110. Avariety of energy director techniques may be used to improve thisgeneral approach. For example, a deposited layer may include one or moreridges, which may be imposed by an exit shape of the nozzle 110, topresent a focused area to receive ultrasound energy introduced into theinterface between the deposited layer and an adjacent layer.

In another aspect, the nozzle 110 may include an induction heatingelement, resistive heating element, or similar components to directlycontrol the temperature of the nozzle 110. This may be used to augment amore general liquefaction process along the feed path through theprinter 100, e.g., to maintain a temperature of the build material 102during fabrication, or this may be used for more specific functions,such as declogging a print head by heating the build material 102substantially above the working range, e.g., to a temperature where thecomposite is liquid. While it may be difficult or impossible to controldeposition in this liquid state, the heating can provide a convenienttechnique to reset the nozzle 110 without more severe physicalintervention such as removing vacuum to disassemble, clean, and replacethe affected components.

In another aspect, the nozzle 110 may include an inlet gas or fan, e.g.,an inert gas, to cool media at the moment it exits the nozzle 110. Theresulting gas jet may, for example, immediately stiffen the dispensedmaterial to facilitate extended bridging, larger overhangs, or otherstructures that might otherwise require support structures underneath.

The object 112 may be any object suitable for fabrication using thetechniques described herein. This may include functional objects such asmachine parts, aesthetic objects such as sculptures, or any other typeof objects, as well as combinations of objects that can be fit withinthe physical constraints of the build chamber 116 and build plate 114.Some structures such as large bridges and overhangs cannot be fabricateddirectly using fused filament fabrication or the like because there isno underlying physical surface onto which a material can be deposited.In these instances, a support structure 113 may be fabricated,preferably of a soluble or otherwise readily removable material, inorder to support the corresponding feature.

Where multiple nozzles 110 are provided, a second nozzle may usefullyprovide any of a variety of additional build materials. This may, forexample, include other composites, alloys, bulk metallic glass's,thermally matched polymers and so forth to support fabrication ofsuitable support structures. In one aspect, one of the nozzles 110 maydispense a bulk metallic glass that is deposited at one temperature tofabricate a support structure 113, and a second, higher temperature atan interface to a printed object 112 where the bulk metallic glass canbe crystallized at the interface to become more brittle and facilitatemechanical removal of the support structure 113 from the object 112.Conveniently, the bulk form of the support structure 113 can be left inthe super-cooled state so that it can retain its bulk structure and beremoved in a single piece. Thus in one aspect there is described hereina printer that fabricates a portion of a support structure 113 with abulk metallic glass in a super-cooled liquid region, and fabricates alayer of the support structure adjacent to a printed object at a greatertemperature in order to crystalize the build material 102 into anon-amorphous alloy. The bulk metallic glass particles may thus beloaded into a MIM feedstock binder system and may provide a support.Pure binding or polymer materials (e.g., without any loading) may alsoor instead provide a support. A similar metal MIM feedstock may be usedfor multi-material part creation. Ceramic or dissimilar metal MIMfeedstock may be used for a support interface material.

Support Materials

In general, the MIM media includes a binder and a metal powder (or othermaterial as described herein, such as ceramic powder). A supportmaterial may also be provided from a second nozzle consisting of, e.g.,the binder used for the injection molding material, without thestructural material that sinters into the final object. In anotheraspect, the support material may be formed of a wax, or some otherthermoplastic or other polymer that can be removed during processing ofa printed green body. This support material may, for example, be usedfor vertical supports, as well as for top or side supports, or any othersuitable support structures to provide a physical support duringprinting and subsequent sintering. Printing and sintering may imposedifferent support requirements. As such, different support materials andor different support rules may be employed for each type of requiredsupport. Additionally, the print supports may be removed after a printand before sintering, while sintering supports would be left attached tothe green object until sintering is completed (or sufficiently completedto eliminate the need for the sintering support structures).

In another aspect, the second nozzle (or a third nozzle) may be used toprovide an interface material that is different from the supportmaterial, such as the corresponding binder, along with a ceramic or someother material that will not sinter under the time and temperatureconditions used to sinter the injection molding material. This may alsoor instead include a metal or the like that forms a brittle interfacewith the sintered part so that it can break away from the final objecteasily after sintering. Where this interface material does not sinter,it may be used in combination with a sinterable support structure thatcan continue to provide structural support during a sintering process.

The support material(s) may usefully integrate other functionalsubstances. For example, titanium may be added to the support materialas an oxygen getter to improve the build environment without introducingany titanium into the fabricated object. Other types of additives mayalso or instead be used to remove contaminants. For example, a zirconiumpowder (or other strong carbide former) may be added to the supportmaterial in order to extract carbon contamination during sintering.

Nested Parts

In one aspect, the use of non-structural support at the interface, e.g.a pure binder that does not sinter into a structural object, may be usedto facilitate the additive manufacture of nested parts. For example, acomplete gear box or the like may be fabricated within an enclosure,with the surfaces between gear teeth fabricated with a non-sinteringbinder or other material. In one aspect, critical mechanical interfacesfor such mechanical parts may be oriented to the fabrication process,e.g., by orienting mating surfaces vertically so that smallerresolutions can be used. More generally, the capability to printadjacent, non-coupled parts may be used to fabricate multiple physicallyrelated parts in a single print job. This may, for example, includehinges, gears, captive bearings or other nested or interrelated parts.Non-sintering support material may be extracted, e.g., using anultrasonicator, fluid cleaning, or other techniques after the object issintered to a final form. In an aspect, the binder is loaded with anon-sintering additive such as ceramic or dissimilar, higher sinteringtemp metal.

This general approach may also affect the design of the part. Forexample, axles may employ various anti-backlash techniques so that thesintered part is more securely retained during movement and use.Similarly, fluid paths may be provided for fluid cleaning, and removalpaths may be created for interior support structures. This technique mayalso be used to address other printing challenges. For example, supportstructures within partially enclosed spaces may be fabricated forremoval through some removal path after the object is completed. If thesupport structures are weakly connected, or unconnected, to thefabricated object, they can be physically manipulated for extractionthrough the removal path. In an aspect, parts may be “glued” togetherwith an appropriate (e.g., the same) MIM material to make larger partsthat essentially have no joints once sintered.

The build plate 114 within the working volume 115 of the build chamber116 may include a rigid and substantially planar surface formed of anysubstance suitable for receiving deposited composite or othermaterial(s)s from the nozzles 110. In one aspect, the build plate 114may be heated, e.g., resistively or inductively, to control atemperature of the build chamber 116 or the surface upon which theobject 112 is being fabricated. This may, for example, improve adhesion,prevent thermally induced deformation or failure, and facilitaterelaxation of stresses within the fabricated object. In another aspect,the build plate 114 may be a deformable build plate that can bend orotherwise physical deform in order to detach from the rigid object 112formed thereon.

The build chamber 116 may be any chamber suitable for containing thebuild plate 114, an object 112, and any other components of the printer100 used within the build chamber 116 to fabricate the object 112. Inone aspect, the build chamber 116 may be an environmentally sealedchamber that can be evacuated with a vacuum pump 124 or similar devicein order to provide a vacuum environment for fabrication. This may beparticularly useful where oxygen causes a passivation layer that mightweaken layer-to-layer bonds in a fused filament fabrication process asdescribed herein, or where particles in the atmosphere might otherwiseinterfere with the integrity of a fabricated object, or where the buildchamber 116 is the same as the sintering chamber. In another aspect,only oxygen is removed from the build chamber 116.

Similarly, one or more passive or active oxygen getters 126 or othersimilar oxygen absorbing material or system may usefully be employedwithin the build chamber 116 to take up free oxygen within the buildchamber 116. The oxygen getter 126 may, for example, include a depositof a reactive material coating an inside surface of the build chamber116 or a separate object placed therein that completes and maintains thevacuum by combining with or adsorbing residual gas molecules. The oxygengetters 126, or more generally, gas getters, may be deposited as asupport material using one of the nozzles 110, which facilitatesreplacement of the gas getter with each new fabrication run and canadvantageously position the gas getter(s) near printed media in order tomore locally remove passivating gasses where new material is beingdeposited onto the fabricated object. In one aspect, the oxygen getters126 may include any of a variety of materials that preferentially reactwith oxygen including, e.g., materials based on titanium, aluminum, andso forth. In another aspect, the oxygen getters 126 may include achemical energy source such as a combustible gas, gas torch, catalyticheater, Bunsen burner, or other chemical and/or combustion source thatreacts to extract oxygen from the environment. There are a variety oflow-CO and NOx catalytic burners that may be suitably employed for thispurpose without CO.

In one aspect, the oxygen getter 126 may be deposited as a separatematerial during a build process. Thus in one aspect there is describedherein a process for fabricating a three-dimensional object from ametallic composite including co-fabricating a physically adjacentstructure (which may or may not directly contact the three-dimensionalobject) containing an agent to remove passivating gasses around thethree-dimensional object. Other techniques may be similarly employed tocontrol reactivity of the environment within the build chamber 116, orwithin post-processing chambers or the like as described below. Forexample, the build chamber 116 may be filled with an inert gas or thelike to prevent oxidation.

The control system 118 may include a processor and memory, as well asany other co-processors, signal processors, inputs and outputs,digital-to-analog or analog-to-digital converters and other processingcircuitry useful for monitoring and controlling a fabrication processexecuting on the printer 100. The control system 118 may be coupled in acommunicating relationship with a supply of the build material 102, thedrive train 104, the liquefaction system 106, the nozzles 110, the buildplate 114, the robotic system 108, and any other instrumentation orcontrol components associated with the build process such as temperaturesensors, pressure sensors, oxygen sensors, vacuum pumps, and so forth.The control system 118 may be operable to control the robotic system108, the liquefaction system 106 and other components to fabricate anobject 112 from the build material 102 in three dimensions within theworking volume 115 of the build chamber 116.

The control system 118 may generate machine ready code for execution bythe printer 100 to fabricate the object 112 from the three-dimensionalmodel 122. The control system 118 may deploy a number of strategies toimprove the resulting physical object structurally or aesthetically. Forexample, the control system 118 may use plowing, ironing, planing, orsimilar techniques where the nozzle 110 runs over existing layers ofdeposited material, e.g., to level the material, remove passivationlayers, apply an energy director topography of peaks or ridges toimprove layer-to-layer bonding, or otherwise prepare the current layerfor a next layer of material. The nozzle 110 may include a low-frictionor non-stick surface such as Teflon, TiN or the like to facilitate thisplowing process, and the nozzle 110 may be heated and/or vibrated (e.g.,using an ultrasound transducer) to improve the smoothing effect. In oneaspect, this surface preparation may be incorporated into theinitially-generated machine ready code. In another aspect, the printer100 may dynamically monitor deposited layers and determine, on alayer-bylayer basis, whether additional surface preparation is necessaryor helpful for successful completion of the object.

In one aspect, the control system 118 may employ pressure or flow rateas a process feedback signal. While temperature is frequently thecritical physical quantity for fabrication with thermoplastic binders,it may be difficult to accurately measure the temperature of a compositebuild material throughout the feed path. However, the temperature can beinferred by the viscosity of the build material, which can be estimatedfor the bulk material based on how much force is being applied to drivethe material through a feed path. Thus in one aspect, there is describedherein a printer that measures the force applied by a drive train to acomposite such as any of the composites described above, infers atemperature of the build material based on the instantaneous force, andcontrols a liquefaction system to adjust the temperature accordingly.

In general, a three-dimensional model 122 of the object may be stored ina database 120 such as a local memory of a computer used as the controlsystem 118, or a remote database accessible through a server or otherremote resource, or in any other computer-readable medium accessible tothe control system 118. The control system 118 may retrieve a particularthree-dimensional model 122 in response to user input, and generatemachine-ready instructions for execution by the printer 100 to fabricatethe corresponding object 112. This may include the creation ofintermediate models, such as where a CAD model is converted into an STLmodel or other polygonal mesh or other intermediate representation,which can in turn be processed to generate machine instructions forfabrication of the object 112 by the printer 100.

In another aspect, the nozzle 110 may include one or more mechanisms toflatten a layer of deposited material and apply pressure to bond thelayer to an underlying layer. For example, a heated nip roller, caster,or the like may follow the nozzle 110 in its path through an x-y planeof the build chamber to flatten the deposited (and still pliable) layer.The nozzle 110 may also or instead integrate a forming wall, planarsurface or the like to additionally shape or constrain a build material102 as it is deposited by the nozzle 110. The nozzle 110 may usefully becoated with a non-stick material (which may vary according to the buildmaterial being used) in order to facilitate more consistent shaping andsmoothing by this tool.

In another aspect, a layer fusion system 132 may be used to encouragegood mechanical bonding between adjacent layers of deposited buildmaterial within the object 112. This may include the ultrasoundtransducers described above, which may be used to facilitate bondingbetween layers by applying ultrasound energy to an interface betweenlayers during deposition. In another aspect, current may be passedthrough an interface between adjacent layers in order to Joule heat theinterface and liquefy or soften the materials for improved bonding. Thusin one aspect, the layer fusion system 132 may include a joule heatingsystem configured to apply a current between a first layer of the buildmaterial and a second layer of the build material in the working volume115 while the first layer is being deposited on the second layer. Inanother aspect, the layer fusion system 132 may include an ultrasoundsystem for applying ultrasound energy to a first layer of the buildmaterial while the first layer is being deposited onto a second layer ofthe build material in the working volume 115. In another aspect, thelayer fusion system 132 may include a rake, ridge(s), notch(es) or thelike formed into the end of the nozzle 110, or a fixture or the likeadjacent to the nozzle, in order to form energy directors on a topsurface of a deposited material. Other techniques may also or instead beused to improve layer-to-layer bonding, such as plasma cleaning or otherdepassivation before or during formation of the interlayer bond. The useof injection molding materials can alleviate many of the difficulties offorming layer-to-layer bonds with deposited metals, but these and othertechniques may nonetheless be useful in improving interlayer bondsand/or shaping a fabricated object as described herein.

During fabrication, detailed data may be gathered for subsequent use andanalysis. This may, for example, include a camera and computer visionsystem that identifies errors, variations, or the like that occur ineach layer of an object. Similarly, tomography or other imagingtechniques may be used to detect and measure layer-to-layer interfaces,aggregate part dimensions, diagnostic information (e.g., defects, voids)and so forth. This data may be gathered and delivered with the object toan end user as a digital twin 140 of the object 112 so that the end usercan evaluate whether and how variations and defects might affect use ofthe object 112. In addition to spatial/geometric analysis, the digitaltwin 140 may log process parameters including, for example, aggregatestatistics such as weight of material used, time of print, variance ofbuild chamber temperature, and so forth, as well as chronological logsof any process parameters of interest such as volumetric depositionrate, material temperature, environment temperature, and so forth.

The printer 100 may include a camera 150 or other optical device. In oneaspect, the camera 150 may be used to create the digital twin 140described above, or to more generally facilitate machine visionfunctions or facilitate remote monitoring of a fabrication process.Video or still images from the camera 150 may also or instead be used todynamically correct a print process, or to visualize where and howautomated or manual adjustments should be made, e.g., where an actualprinter output is deviating from an expected output.

The printer 100 may also usefully integrate a subtractive fabricationtool 160 such as a drill, milling bit, or other multi-axis controllabletool for removing material from the object 112 that deviates from anexpected physical output based on the 3D model 122 used to fabricate theobject 112. While combinations of additive and subtractive technologieshave been described, the use of MIM materials provides a uniqueadvantage when subtractive shaping is performed on a green object afternet shape forming but before sintering (or debinding), when the object112 is relatively soft and workable. This permits quick and easy removalof physically observable defects and printing artifacts before theobject 112 is sintered into a metal object. An aspect may insteadinclude tapping threads or otherwise adding features as opposed tosubtracting parts. Similarly, an aspect may include combining multiplesingle green parts into one larger fully solid sintered part.

Other useful features may be integrated into the printer 100 describedabove. For example, a solvent or other material may be usefully applieda surface of the object 112 during fabrication to modify its properties.This may, for example intentionally oxidize or otherwise modify thesurface at a particular location or over a particular area in order toprovide a desired electrical, thermal optical, or mechanical property.This capability may be used to provide aesthetic features such as textor graphics, or to provide functional features such as a window foradmitting RF signals.

Design Rules

In general, a fabrication process such as fused filament fabricationimplies, or expressly includes, a set of design rules to accommodatephysical limitations of a fabrication device and a build material. Forexample, a horizontal shelf cannot be fabricated without positioning asupport structure underneath. While the design rules for FFF may applyto fabrication of a green body using FFF techniques as described herein,the green body may also be subject to various MIM design rules. Thismay, for example, include a structure to prevent or minimize drag on afloor while a part shrinks during sintering which may be 20% or moredepending on the composition of the green body. Similarly, certainsupports are required during sintering that are different than thesupports required during fused filament fabrication. As another example,injection molding typically aims for uniform wall thickness to reducevariability in debinding and/or sintering behaviors, with thinner wallsbeing preferred. The system described herein may apply to disparate setsof design rules—those for the rapid prototyping system (e.g., fusedfilament fabrication) and those for the sintering process (e.g., MIMdesign rules)—to a CAD model that is being prepared for fabrication.

These rules may also be combined under certain conditions. For example,the support structures for a horizontal shelf during fabrication mustresist the force of an extrusion/deposition process used to fabricatethe horizontal shelf, whereas the support structure during sinteringonly needs to resist the forces of gravity during the baking process.Thus there may be two separate supports that are removed at differenttimes during a fabrication process: the fabrication supports that areconfigured to resist the force of a fabrication process and may bebreakaway supports that are loosely mechanically coupled to a greenbody, along with sintering supports that may be less extensive, and onlyneed to resist the gravitation forces on a body during sintering. Theselatter supports are preferably coupled to the object through anonsinterable layer to permit easy removal from the densified finalobject. In another aspect, the fabrication supports may be fabricatedfrom binder without a powder or other fill so that they completelydisappear during a sintering process.

FIG. 2 shows a flow chart of a method for printing with composites,e.g., metal injection molding materials. As shown in step 202, theprocess 200 may include providing a build material including aninjection molding material, or where a support interface is beingfabricated, a MIM binder (e.g., a MIM binder with similar thermalcharacteristics). The material may include, for example, any of the MIMmaterials described herein. The material may be provided as a buildmaterial in a billet, a wire, or any other cast, drawn, extruded orotherwise shaped bulk form. As described above, the build material maybe further packaged in a cartridge, spool, or other suitable carrierthat can be attached to an additive manufacturing system for use.

As shown in step 204, the process may include fabricating a layer of anobject. This may include any techniques that can be adapted for use withMIM materials. For example, this may include fused filament fabrication,jet printing, selective laser sintering, or any other techniques forforming a net shape from a MIM material (and more specifically fortechniques used for forming a net shape from a polymeric material loadedwith a second phase powder).

As shown in step 211, this process may be continued and repeated asnecessary to fabricate an object within the working volume. While theprocess may vary according to the underlying fabrication technology, anobject can generally be fabricated layer by layer based on athree-dimensional model of the desired object. As shown in step 212, theprocess 200 may include shaping the net shape object after the additiveprocess is complete. Before debinding or sintering, the green body formof the object is usefully in a soft, workable state where defects andprinting artifacts can be easily removed, either manually orautomatically. Thus the process 200 may take advantage of this workable,intermediate state to facilitate quality control or otherprocess-related steps, such as removal of supports that are required forprevious printing steps, but not for debinding or sintering.

As shown in step 214, the process 200 may include debinding the printedobject. In general debinding may be performed chemically or thermally toremove a binder that retains a metal (or ceramic or other) powder in anet shape. Contemporary injection molding materials are often engineeredfor thermal debinding, which advantageously permits debinding andsintering to be performed in a single baking operation, or in twosimilar baking operations. In general, the debinding process functionsto remove binder from the net shape green object, thus leaving a verydense structure of metal (or ceramic or other) particles that can besintered into the final form.

As shown in step 216, the process 200 may include sintering the printedand debound object into a final form. In general, sintering may be anyprocess of compacting and forming a solid mass of material by heatingwithout liquefaction. During a sintering process, atoms can diffuseacross particle boundaries to fuse into a solid piece. Because sinteringcan be performed at temperatures below the melting temperature, thisadvantageously permits fabrication with very high melting pointmaterials such as tungsten and molybdenum.

Numerous sintering techniques are known in the art, and the selection ofa particular technique may depend upon the build material used, and thedesired structural, functional or aesthetic result for the fabricatedobject. For example, in solid-state (non-activated) sintering, metalpowder particles are heated to form connections (or “necks”) where theyare in contact. Over time, these necks thicken and create a dense part,leaving small, interstitial voids that can be closed, e.g., by hotisostatic pressing (HIP) or similar processes. Other techniques may alsoor instead be employed. For example, solid state activated sinteringuses a film between powder particles to improve mobility of atomsbetween particles and accelerate the formation and thickening of necks.As another example, liquid phase sintering may be used, in which aliquid forms around metal particles. This can improve diffusion andjoining between particles, but also may leave lower-melting phase withinthe sintered object that impairs structural integrity. Other advancedtechniques such as nano-phase separation sintering may be used, forexample to form a high-diffusivity solid at the necks to improve thetransport of metal atoms at the contact point

Debinding and sintering may result in material loss and compaction, andthe resulting object may be significantly smaller than the printedobject. However, these effects are generally linear in the aggregate,and net shape objects can be usefully scaled up when printing to createa corresponding shape after debinding and sintering.

FIG. 3 shows an additive manufacturing system for use with metalinjection molding materials. The system 300 may include a printer 302, aconveyor 304, and a postprocessing station 306. In general, the printer302 may be any of the printers described above including, for example afused filament fabrication system, a stereolithography system, aselective laser sintering system, or any other system that can beusefully adapted to form a net shape object under computer control usinginjection molding build materials. The output of the printer 302 may bean object 303 that is a green body including any suitable powder (e.g.,metal, metal alloy, ceramic, and so forth, as well as combinations ofthe foregoing), along with a binder that retains the powder in a netshape produced by the printer 302.

The conveyor 304 may be used to transport the object 303 from theprinter 302 to a post-processing station 306 where debinding andsintering can be performed. The conveyor 304 may be any suitable deviceor combination of devices suitable for physically transporting theobject 303. This may, for example, include robotics and a machine visionsystem or the like on the printer side for detaching the object 303 froma build platform or the like, as well as robotics and a machine visionsystem or the like on the post-processing side to accurately place theobject 303 within the post-processing station 306. In another aspect,the post-processing station 306 may serve multiple printers so that anumber of objects can be debound and sintered concurrently, and theconveyor 304 may interconnect the printers and post-processing stationso that multiple print jobs can be coordinated and automaticallycompleted in parallel. In another aspect, the object 303 may be manuallytransported between the two corresponding stations.

The post-processing station 306 may be any system or combination ofsystems useful for converting a green part formed into a desired netshape from a metal injection molding build material by the printer 302into a final object. The post-processing station 306 may, for example,include a chemical debinding station and a thermal sintering stationthat can be used in sequence to produce a final object. Somecontemporary injection molding materials are engineered for thermaldebinding, which makes it possible to perform a combination of debindingand sintering steps with a single oven or similar device. While thethermal specifications of a sintering furnace may depend upon the powderto be sintered, the binder system, the loading, and other aspects of thegreen object and the materials used to manufacture same, commercialsintering furnaces for thermally debound and sintered MIM parts maytypically operate with an accuracy of +/−5 degrees Celsius or better,and temperatures of at least 600 degrees C., or from about 200 degreesC. to about 1900 degrees C. for extended times. Any such furnace orsimilar heating device may be usefully employed as the post-processingstation 306 as described herein. Vacuum or pressure treatment may alsoor instead be used. In an aspect, identical or similar material beadswith a non-binding coating may be used for a furnace support—e.g.,packing in a bed of this material that shrinks similar to the part,except that it will not bond to the part.

Embodiments may be implemented with a wide range of other debinding andsintering processes. For example, the binder may be removed in achemical debind, thermal debind, or some combination of these. Otherdebinding processes are also known in the art (such as supercritical orcatalytic debinding), any of which may also or instead be employed bythe post-processing station 306 as described herein. For example, in acommon process, a green part is first debound using a chemical debind,which is following by a thermal debind at a moderately high temperature(in this context, around 700-800 C) to remove organic binder and createenough necks among a powdered material to permit handling. From thisstage, the object may be moved to a sintering furnace to remove anyremaining components of a binder system densify the object. In anotheraspect, a pure thermal debind may be used to remove the organic binder.More general, any technique or combination of techniques may be usefullyemployed to debind an object as described herein.

Similarly, a wide range of sintering techniques may be usefully employedby the post-processing station. In one aspect, an object may beconsolidated in a furnace to a high theoretical density using vacuumsintering. In another aspect, the furnace may use a combination offlowing gas (e.g., at below atmosphere, slightly above atmosphere, orsome other suitable pressure) and vacuum sintering. More generally, anysintering or other process suitable for improving object density may beused, preferably where the process yields a near-theoretical densitypart with little or no porosity. Hot-isostatic pressing (“HIP”) may also(e.g., as a postsinter finishing step) or instead be employed, e.g., byapplying elevated temperatures and pressures of 10-50 ksi, or betweenabout 15 and 30 ksi. In another aspect, the object may be processedusing any of the foregoing, followed by a moderate overpressure (greaterthan the sintering pressure, but lower than HIP pressures). In thislatter process, gas may be pressurized at 100-1500 psi and maintained atelevated temperatures within the furnace or some other supplementalchamber. In another aspect, the object may be separately heated in onefurnace, and then immersed in a hot granular media inside a die, withpressure applied to the media so that it can be transmitted to theobject to drive more rapid consolidation to near full density. Moregenerally, any technique or combination of techniques suitable forremoving binder systems and driving a powdered material towardconsolidation and densification may be used by the post-processingstation 306 to process a fabricated green part as described herein.

In one aspect, the post-processing station 306 may be incorporated intothe printer 302, thus removing a need for a conveyor 304 to physicallytransport the object 303. The build volume of the printer 302 andcomponents therein may be fabricated to withstand the elevateddebinding/sintering temperatures. In another aspect, the printer 302 mayprovide movable walls, barriers, or other enclosure(s) within the buildvolume so that the debind/sinter can be performed while the object 303is on a build platform within the printer 302, but thermally isolatedfrom any thermally sensitive components or materials.

The post-processing station 306 may be optimized in a variety of waysfor use in an office environment. In one aspect, the post-processingstation 306 may include an inert gas source 308. The inert gas source308 may, for example, include argon or other inert gas (or other gasthat is inert to the sintered material), and may be housed in aremovable and replaceable cartridge that can be coupled to thepost-processing station 306 for discharge into the interior of thepost-processing station 306, and then removed and replaced when thecontents are exhausted. The post-processing station 306 may also orinstead include a filter 310 such as a charcoal filter or the like forexhausting gasses that can be outgassed into an office environment in anunfiltered form. For other gasses, an exterior exhaust, or a gascontainer or the like may be provided to permit use in unventilatedareas. For reclaimable materials, a closed system may also or instead beused, particularly where the environmental materials are expensive ordangerous.

In one aspect, the post-processing station 306 may be coupled to othersystem components. For example, the post-processing station 306 mayinclude information from the printer 302, or from a controller for theprinter, about the geometry, size, mass and other physicalcharacteristics of the object 303 in order to generate a suitabledebinding and sintering profile. In another aspect, the profile may beindependently created by the controller or other resource andtransmitted to the post-processing station 306 when the object 303 isconveyed. In another aspect, the post-processing station 306 may monitorthe debinding and sintering process and provide feedback, e.g., to asmart phone or other remote device 312, about a status of the object, atime to completion, and other processing metrics and information. Thepost-processing station 306 may include a camera 314 or other monitoringdevice to provide feedback to the remote device 312, and may providetime lapse animation or the like to graphically show sintering on acompressed time scale. Post-processing may also or instead includefinishing with heat, a hot knife, tools, or similar, and may includeapplying a finish coat.

Microwave Sintering

In one aspect, the post-processing station 306 may employ microwavesintering to accelerate post processing. Powdered metals in particularare very good absorbers of microwave energy and can be efficientlyheated using microwave techniques. Ceramics can also be sintered in thismanner, where microwave heating is linked to the dielectric loss of thematerial and other factors. Any other configuration suitable formicrowave heating in an amount and for a duration suitable for sinteringof MIM materials may also or instead be employed. Where the bindersystem of the build material is also engineered for thermal debinding,the method may include debinding the green object by applying microwaveenergy, e.g., using the post-processing station 306 described above.

Stereolithography with MIM Materials

FIG. 4 illustrates a stereolithography process using a metallic powderand an ultraviolet-curable binder. In general, a build material may beformed using an injection molding powder, such as any of those describedherein, along with an ultraviolet-curable binder such as any suitablephotopolymer resin that can be cured using stereolithography. This buildmaterial may be cured on a layer-by-layer basis with an ultravioletlaser using known stereolithography techniques to form a UV-cured greenbody having a shape of the desired object. MIM powders may generally beopaque, and adaptations to the laser light source may be used to improvethe structural integrity of the fabricated green object, such as using alayer size equal to or less than an average powder diameter, orproviding laser light from multiple sources/directions in order toreduce or minimize occlusion of the UV resin at each layer. In anotheraspect, there is described herein a sinterable, net shape green bodyobject based formed according to a computer model and including a basematerial in powder form and an ultraviolet curable (orultraviolet-cured) resin that can be debound and/or sintered into afinal object, as well as a process for sintering an object comprising abase material in powder form and an ultraviolet-cured resin. Themetallic powder may be suspended within an ultraviolet-curable binder,creating a slurry or suspension. The mass and surface area of theparticles versus the specific rheology of the binder may dictate whetheror not the powder will float indefinitely or settle due to gravity.Using nano sized particles may optimize the powders ability to form astable suspension that does not settle (over reasonable timescales).

In order to reduce binder char and subsequent carbon contamination andincrease shape retention, the binder may usefully be composed of twoparts—a UV curable resin and a second component that may be removed(e.g. debound) prior to insertion into the furnace. Similarmulticomponent binder formulations have been shown to reduce carbonpickup from the burnout process and reduce part failures by buildup ofgases inside the part. Many possible binder combinations exist,including poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) as a solvent-soluble componentthat may be removed prior to insertion into the furnace, along with abackbone based on poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEG-DA), or anynumber of other UV curable resins.

The ultraviolet-curable resin may, for example include a commerciallyavailable investment casting resin engineered for stereolithographyfabrication, or any other suitable UV curable resin or the like. The UVcurable resin may usefully incorporate an increased concentration of anactivating die (at least 50% greater than typical commercially availableUV curable resins) to compensate for optical interference of opaqueparticles.

In another aspect, the process may be modified to address particleopacity in other ways. For example, the current layer may be coated withpolymer (e.g., by moving the object along the z-axis within a bath,either up or down according to the species of stereolithography beingemployed), and then a powder may be introduced, after which the layermay be cured in a desired cross section using UV exposure. In anotheraspect, the layer may be cured, powdered, and then coated with anotherlayer of powder, so that the resin is fully exposed to the UV stimulusbefore coating with an additional powder layer.

In another aspect, the mixture of a MIM powder and a UV-curable resinmay be dispensed and cured on the fly in order to remove or reduce theneed for a resin holding tank. More generally, any technique for localthermal activation of a binder may be used in combination with a powderbed of MIM material (and binder) as described herein to form a greenbody. For example, targeted thermal activation may be achieved with athermal print head, an IR heating mask and/or lamp, focused microwaveenergy, selective thermal sintering, steering of an activation beam witha digital light processing chip, a heated roller, or any other techniqueor combination of techniques. For example, a variety of thermal printheads are commercially available, e.g., from Kyocera and othermanufacturers that may be suitably adapted to applying targeted thermalenergy to a layer of binder and MIM powder.

SLS with MIM Materials

FIG. 5 shows a laser binding process for powder metallurgy materials. Ina process comparable to selective laser sintering, a powder/bindermixture may be fed from a powder delivery system to a fabrication bed.The binder may be activated on a layer-by-layer basis using a laser orother activation source to create a low strength bond within the powderfor each cross section of a target shape. This activation may form asufficient bond to retain the powder and binder in a net shape greenbody that can be removed and sintered using the sintering processesdescribed herein. Suitable binders are available that can be activatedusing relatively inexpensive, lowpower, fast laser processes or maskedIR or UV. This significantly improves upon existing direct metal lasersintering processes that would otherwise require special atmosphericcontrols and high-power lasers.

Higher energy lasers may be usefully employed, for example, to morefully melt and/or remove binder material and improve the density of thegreen body before sintering, or to initiate sintering of the metalwithin the green body. In another aspect, the MIM materials describedherein may be adapted for use in a selective laser melting process wherethe binder melts, rather than sinters, to form a net-shape green bodywhich is then debound and sintered according to the methods describedherein.

FIGS. 6A-B illustrate camera and print head assembly 600 within a buildchamber in one embodiment. FIG. 6A shows a lateral (i.e.,cross-sectional) view of the assembly 600 and build plate 605, whileFIG. 6B depicts a plan (“top-down”) view. The assembly 600 may beimplemented in a build chamber of a 3D printer described above withreference to FIGS. 1-5. In particular, the assembly 600 may be a featureof a 3D printer such as the printer 100 described above, and the object612 and build plate 605 may incorporate one or more features of theobject 112, and build plate 114, respectively, as described above withreference to FIG. 1. Prior to or during printing, the geometry of theobject 612 may be defined by a three-dimensional model comparable to themodel 122 described above with reference to FIG. 1. An interface layer608 may occupy a layer between the build plate 605 and the base plate610. The interface layer 608 may include a material that is nonreactiverelative to the material comprising the base plate 610, such as apowdered ceramic, thereby facilitating separation of the assembly 600from the build plate 605 after the printing process is completed.Following printing, the object 612 (as a green part) may undergo furtherprocessing as described above, including debinding and sintering, toproduce a finished object.

The assembly 600 may include a print head 620, a camera 630, and a mount645 connecting to a shaft 655 suspending the assembly 600 within thebuild chamber. A robotic system, such as the robotic system 108described above with reference to FIG. 1, may operate to move theassembly 600 along the shaft 655, through the space of the buildchamber, and along a tool path to print the object 612. The camera 630may include one or more sensors, including an image sensor, astereoscopic (i.e., 3D) camera, a distance sensor (e.g., laser orinfrared distance sensor), and/or other devices for imaging ormeasurements. As shown in FIG. 6B, during such operation, the camera 630may capture an image 635 of scenes below the assembly 600, which caninclude the object 612 and/or the build plate 605. Further, during aprinting operation, when a given layer of the object 612 is beingprinted via the print head 620, the camera can capture images of thelayer concurrently with the printing. As a result, the assembly 600 cancapture image data of the object at various stages of the print process.In alternative embodiments, the camera 630 may be implemented separatelyfrom the print head 620. For example, the camera 630 may be mounted at astationary location within the printer, or may be mounted to an assemblyconnected to a motion system to move independently from the print head620.

The assembly 600, and image data captured by the camera 630 of theassembly 600, can be applied in several ways to improve the printing ofobjects by the 3D printer. For example, the assembly 600 can captureimage data of the build plate 605, and, based on this image data,correct for any defects or deviations in the build plate 605 whenbuilding an object. An example embodiment of such a method is describedbelow with reference to FIGS. 7A-B and 8. Similarly, the assembly 600can also scan a calibration object, such as a pattern printed on thebuild plate 605, and implement the corresponding image data to improvethe printing of a subsequent object, as described below with referenceto FIGS. 9A-B and 10. Further, the assembly 600 can scan successiveportions of an object, on a layer-by-layer basis, as the object is beingprinted. The resulting image data can be implemented to detect anydefects in the printed object, and make corresponding corrections toimprove the printing of successive objects, as described below withreference to FIGS. 11A-B and 14. In further embodiments, corrections orimprovements to a printed object may be made in response to a scan ofthe object itself, as described below with reference to FIG. 15.

FIGS. 7A-B illustrate a camera and print head assembly 600 during a scanof a build plate 605. As shown in FIG. 6A, the assembly 600 may be movedalong a tool path 660 above the surface of the build plate 605, and theassembly 600 captures a plurality of images 636 a-n along the tool path660. The images 636 a-n may together capture the entire surface of thebuild plate 605, as well as an area beyond the build plate 605, or mayencompass a subset of the build plate 605 constituting an area on whichan object is to be built. Further, each of the images 636 a-n mayoverlap with one or more other images, as shown for example by images636 a-c. Alternatively, the assembly 600 may capture images havingoverlaps such that every portion of the build plate is captured by atleast two images.

The images 636 a-n may be implemented in a number of ways to determineinformation about the build plate 605. For example, the images 636 a-nmay be “stitched” together to form a single, 2D image at a higherresolution than what would be captured by a single image. In a furtherapplication, the overlapping images can provide stereoscopic data aboutthe surface of the build plate 605, enabling a control system (e.g.,control system 118 of FIG. 1) to resolve 3D features of the build platesurface. In place of (or in addition to) the use of overlapping images,the assembly 600 may employ a stereoscopic camera to capture multiple,offset images simultaneously. Using the stereoscopic data, the controlsystem may derive a depth map of the build plate surface, whichindicates deviations from a defined plane at a surface of the buildplate 605. Alternatively, the assembly 600 may be controlled to capturea single (flat or stereoscopic) image encompassing the entire buildplate 605, avoiding the need for stitching of multiple images.

As shown in FIG. 7B, the surface of the build plate 605 may includedefects 691, 692 that amount to deviations from a defined plane (e.g., afirst build layer) making up the expected work surface. These defects,such as a pit 691 and a warped portion 692, can introduce flaws into theprinting of an object due to misplacement of build material at thesurface of the build plate 605. By capturing the images 636 a-n, acontrol system can identify these defects 691, 692 and implementmeasures into a print process to compensate for those defects, resultingan object printed with higher fidelity. As an alternative or supplementto a camera, the assembly 600 may implement a distance sensor (e.g.,laser or infrared sensor) to measure the distance (referred to as“Z-dimension” 637) between the assembly 600 and the surface of the buildplate 605. In addition to improving the accuracy of a depth map of thesurface of the build plate 605, the distance sensor may also beimplemented during a calibration process or a printing operation toadjust the height of the assembly 600 above the build plate 605 as afunction of the measured Z-dimension 637. The assembly 600 may employother solutions for determining the Z-dimension 637, such as measuringthe width of a beam of light directed at the surface of the build plate605, or employing a camera with a narrow focus range.

FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of a process of scanning and a surface of abuild plate and calibrating a printer based on the scan. The process 800may be carried out by a printer and associated control system such asthe printer 100 and control system 118 described above with reference toFIG. 1, where the printer may implement the assembly 600 of FIGS. 7A-B.With reference to FIGS. 1 and 7A-B, a control system 118 may control theassembly 600 to scan the surface of the build plate 605 (805). Forexample, the assembly 600 may be moved along the tool path 660 tocapture the plurality of images 636 a-n. Alternatively, the assembly 600may capture a single image, or may also obtain distance measurements(e.g., Z-dimension 637) via a component distance sensor. If multipleimages are taken, those images 636 a-n may be stitched together to forma single, high resolution image (810). Utilizing depth data (from one ormore of distance sensor measurements or stereoscopic data from theimages), a depth map of the build plate 605 may also be generated, whichmay indicate the deviations from a defined plane at a surface of thebuild plate 605 (e.g., by indicating relative depth or Z-dimension 637at a plurality of points at the build plate 605).

Using the image data and/or depth map, defects 691, 692 may beidentified (815). Data regarding those defects 691, 692 may be storedfor later reference during printing of an object. In particular, thefootprint of an object (i.e., area of contact with the build plate 605)to be built may be compared against the location of the defects (820).

If it is determined that those defects may introduce errors into theobject printing, a print configuration may be updated to avoid orcompensate for those errors (825). The print configuration may encompassone or more properties and/or configurations defining operation of theprinter. For example, the print configuration may define a subset of thebuild plate 605 as a “work area” on which a footprint of an object maybe printed, and another subset as a “restricted area” on which afootprint of an object may not be printed. The print configuration maydefine a restricted area to encompass the defects 691, 692 in the buildplate 605, thereby preventing the assembly 600 from printing any portionof an object at the defects 691, 692. The print configuration may alsobe updated to modify the location and/or orientation of a referenceplane (e.g., a plane in which a layer of an object, such as the firstlayer, is to be print) to compensate for a slope in the build plate 605.Such a modified plane may be referred to as an offset plane. Theconfiguration of the motion system (e.g., robotics controlling theassembly 600) may also be modified. Further, the print parameters maycontrol material deposition flow rate from the assembly 600, as afunction of tool location and the print configuration, to compensate forthe defects 691,692 when printing at or proximate to the defects 691,692. For example, the pit 691 may be filled in by additional feedstockduring a printing process, thereby compensating for the defect. Theprint properties may be maintained as firmware or operational softwareof the printer. The object may then be printed under the updated printparameters, producing an accurate printed object notwithstanding thedefects 691, 692 of the build plate 605.

Alternatively or in addition, print parameters that are specific to theprinting of a given object may be modified to compensate for thedefects. For example, a model of an object (e.g., the 3D model 122 ordigital twin 140 described above with reference to FIG. 1) may bemodified to incorporate one or more compensations comparable to thosedescribed above, directing the printer to print the object withcompensation for the defects 691, 692. For example, the object model maybe repositioned or reoriented, or the geometry of the model may bemodified (e.g., with portions of greater or lesser feedstock deposition)to compensate for the defects 691, 692 when printing the object,resulting in a printed object with greater fidelity to the originalmodel. As an alternative to modifying an object model, the tool path fora printed object (e.g., a G-code instruction set) may be modified in acomparable manner to incorporate compensations for defects of the buildplate 605.

FIGS. 9A-B illustrate a printed calibration pattern 662 on the buildplate 605. As an alternative or supplement to scanning the build plate605 as described above, the printer may control the assembly 600 toprint and scan the calibration pattern 662. The assembly 600 may scanand print the calibration pattern 662 concurrently, or may scan thepattern 662 during a subsequent operation, such as a scan of the buildplate 605 described above with reference to FIG. 7A.

The pattern 662, as shown in FIG. 9A, includes a plurality ofintersecting printed lines. Alternatively, the pattern 662 may form oneor more geometric shapes, repeating or otherwise, or may occupy multipleprinted layers at and above the build plate 605. Alternatively, thepattern 662 may be printed by more than one different print nozzles orprint heads (e.g., via a print head 620 having multiple nozzles, or viamultiple independent print heads implemented in a common build chamber).In such an embodiment, the pattern 662 may include parallel or adjacentportions that are printed by two different print heads or nozzles, and ascan of the pattern 662 may indicate whether the two print heads ornozzles are correctly calibrated with respect to one another.

The pattern 662 may be printed from the same feedstock utilized to printan object or supporting structure, or may be printed from a materialused for an interface layer (e.g., a ceramic powder occupying a layeradjacent to the object) or other material. To facilitate removal of thepattern 662 following a scan, the assembly 600 may print an interfacelayer between the pattern 662 and the build plate 605. Alternatively, aninterface layer may be applied manually to be build plate 605 prior toprinting the pattern 662.

FIG. 9B illustrates the assembly 600 during a concurrent scan andprinting of a printed line 672. The printed line 672 may be a segment ofthe pattern 662 of FIG. 9A, and may be printed along a programmed toolpath 660 followed by the assembly 600. During the printing, the printedline may exhibit a deviation 674 from the expected line defined by thetool path 660. The deviation 674 may include printing material outsidethe expected bounds of the line 672, a gap in the line 672, or anotherdefect. The deviation 674 may indicate a defect in the build plate 605(e.g., defects 691, 692 of FIG. 7B), and/or may indicate an error in theconfiguration of the printer, such as the calibration of the motionsystem or location or orientation of the assembly 600. The assembly 600scans the printed line 672 to capture an image 637 of the deviation 674.The image 637 may be processed to determine the cause of the deviationand update print parameters as necessary to correct for such defects orerrors.

FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of a process 1000 of calibrating a printerbased on a printed calibration pattern. The process 1000 may be carriedout by a printer and associated control system such as the printer 100and control system 118 described above with reference to FIG. 1, wherethe printer may implement the assembly 600 of FIGS. 9A-B. With referenceto FIGS. 1 and 9A-B, a control system 118 may control the assembly 600to print and scan, concurrently, the pattern 662 on the surface of thebuild plate 605 (1005). During the scan, the assembly 600 may capture animage 637 of defects in the pattern 662, such as the deviation 674. Ifmultiple images are taken, those images may be stitched together to forma single, high resolution image. Utilizing depth data (from one or moreof distance sensor measurements or stereoscopic data from the images), adepth map of the build plate 605 may also be generated, which mayindicate the deviations from a defined plane at a surface of the buildplate 605 (e.g., by indicating relative depth or Z-dimension 637 at aplurality of points at the build plate 605). Further, a positional errorvectormap may be produced based on the depiction of the calibrationpattern 662.

Using the image data, error vectormap and/or depth map, defects, such asprinted deviations from the toolpath, may be identified and compiled(1010). Once compiled, the deviations may be used to update the printconfiguration (1020), which may include configuration settingsindependent of a particular object to be printed. Such configurationsettings may include those described above with reference to FIG. 8,such as a defined “work area,” orientation of a reference plane,configuration of the motion system, and/or material deposition flowrate. Further, data regarding the defects may be stored for laterreference during printing of an object, and may be used to modifyoperations specific to the printing of the object (e.g., printparameters). In particular, the defects may be correlated to the objectto be printed (1015), and print parameters may be updated to avoid orcompensate for the defects during the printing of the objects (e.g., byrepositioning or reorienting the layout of the object within the buildchamber). The object may then be printed based on the updated printconfiguration (1025).

Alternatively or in addition, a model of an object (e.g., the 3D model122 or digital twin 140 described above with reference to FIG. 1) may bemodified to incorporate one or more compensations comparable to thosedescribed above, directing the printer to print the object withcompensation for the defects determined by the calibration pattern 662.For example, the object model may be repositioned or reoriented, or thegeometry of the model may be modified (e.g., with portions of greater orlesser feedstock deposition) to compensate for the deviation 674 whenprinting the object, resulting in a printed object with greater fidelityto the original model. As an alternative to modifying an object model,the tool path for a printed object (e.g., a G-code instruction set) maybe modified in a comparable manner to incorporate compensations for thedetected defects.

FIGS. 11A-B illustrate a camera and print head assembly during a printof portions of an object. FIG. 11A depicts a plan view of an assembly600 printing a first layer of an object (“object layer 1”), while FIG.11B depicts a plan view of the assembly printing a second layer of theobject (“object layer 2”). The assembly 600 may be implemented in abuild chamber of a 3D printer described above with reference to FIGS.1-5. In particular, the assembly 600 may be a feature of a 3D printersuch as the printer 100 described above, and the printed line 682 may bea portion of an object (e.g., object 612) that may incorporate one ormore features of the object 112 as described above with reference toFIG. 1. Prior to or during printing, the geometry of the object may bedefined by a three-dimensional model comparable to the model 122described above with reference to FIG. 1.

At the first object layer shown in part FIG. 11A, the printed line 682may be a segment of the object being printed, and may be printed along aprogrammed tool path 661 followed by the assembly 600. During theprinting, the printed line 682 may exhibit a deviation 675 from theexpected line defined by the tool path 660. The deviation 675 mayinclude any printing result that does not match the print instructed bythe tool path 661. The deviation 675 may indicate a defect in the buildplate 605 (e.g., defects 691, 692 of FIG. 7B), and/or may indicate anerror in the configuration of the printer, such as the calibration ofthe motion system or location or orientation of the assembly 600. Theassembly 600 scans the printed line 682 to capture a series of images638 a-n along the printed line 682, capturing image data of thedeviation 675. The image data may be processed to determine the cause ofthe deviation and update print parameters as necessary to correct forsuch defects or errors.

The second object layer, shown in part in FIG. 11B, may constitute afurther layer of the same object depicted in FIG. 11A, and may beadjacent or non-adjacent to the first object layer. The printed line 683may be a segment of the object being printed, and may be printed along aprogrammed tool path 662 followed by the assembly 600. During theprinting, the printed line 683 may exhibit a defect 676 from theexpected line defined by the tool path 662. The deviation 674 mayindicate a defect in the build plate 605, and/or may indicate an errorin the configuration of the printer, such as the calibration of themotion system or location or orientation of the assembly 600. Theassembly 600 captures an image 639 of the deviation 675. The image datamay be processed to determine the cause of the deviation and updateprint parameters as necessary to correct for such defects or errors.

The defect 676 of the second object layer is depicted as a gap in twoadjacent portions of the printed line 683. Such a defect, due to itsrepetition, may indicate a repeatable (rather than a non-repeatable)error. A repeatable error may be considered to be an error that islikely to occur again during printing of a successive object, or in asuccessive layer of the same object. A control system may be configuredto actuate a reconfiguration in response to detecting a repeated error,while refraining from correcting for errors determined to benon-repeatable. Alternatively, the defect 676 may arise as a length ofinsufficient deposition of material, which may be indicated by a printline that is narrower than that specified by the tool path. Further, thedefect 676 may be indicated by a measured offset between two parallelprinted lines, where the offset differs from the printed lines predictedby the tool path.

In addition to the first and second layers of FIGS. 11A-B, the assemblycan scan additional layers of an object concurrently with the printingof those layers. Thus, the assembly 600 can scan successive portions ofan object, on a layer-by-layer basis, as the object is being printed.The resulting image data can be implemented to detect defects in theprinted object, determine whether those defects are repeatable,determine the source of those defects (e.g., a defective build plate, anerror in the configuration of the motion system), and make correspondingcorrections to improve the printing of successive objects and/orsuccessive layers of the same object.

In further embodiments, images of a plurality of cross-sectional layersof a first object (e.g., the object depicted in FIGS. 11A-B) may becaptured concurrently with the printing of the first object. Based onthe scan, print parameters may be updated, which may include modifyingthe geometry of a representation of the object based on deviationsbetween an initial object model and the images of the plurality ofcross-sectional layers of the first object. Updating the printparameters may also include generating a correction tool path (e.g., arevised version of tool paths 661, 662) for a print head of the assembly600 based on the detected deviations. A second object may then beprinted by controlling the print head based on the correction tool path.Further, during printing of the second object or successive layers ofthe first object, material deposition flow rate may be controlled as afunction of tool location and the correction tool path. The correctiontool path may also be implemented to correct the printing of the firstobject, by printing an initial portion of the object, and then printinga successive portion of the first object according to the correctiontool path. Further updating the print parameters may include generatinga correction model of the object, the correction model defining geometryof the object with offsets to the initial model based on the detecteddeviations. Example methods of such correction are described in furtherdetail below with reference to FIGS. 14 and 15.

FIGS. 12A-B are block diagrams of error data in one embodiment. FIG. 12Adepicts a table 1200 of correction data, while FIG. 12B depicts anexample entry 1205 within the table 1200. The table 1200 may be compiledby a printer control system (e.g., system 118 of FIG. 1) during orfollowing the concurrent scanning and printing of an object, such as theprocesses described above with reference to FIGS. 6A-11B, and each entry(e.g., entry 1205) in the table 1200 may correspond to a detected error(e.g., deviation or defect) in the printed object. The table 1200 mayinclude a plurality of rows, where each row corresponds to a given layerof the printed object (e.g., layers 1-N). Each row may be populated byentries corresponding to the detected error(s) in the printing of therespective layer.

The example entry 1205 includes an address field (ADDR[0,31]) and adescriptor field (DESCR[32,47]). The address field may indicate thelocation of the error within the layer. The address field may includevalues to indicate the 3D and/or 2D coordinates of the error (includingthe bounds or extent of the error), or may express the location as alength along the toolpath for the given layer. The descriptor field mayinclude a plurality of data points regarding the properties of theerror. These data points may include an error category (e.g., omissionof material, deviation of material from the toolpath, excess materialbuildup, insufficient deposition of material), and information specificto the error category (e.g., measured dimensions of the deviation fromthe toolpath). The descriptor may also include a pointer to a portion ofstored image data depicting the error, or may include the image dataitself.

A control system may process the entries of the table 1200 to determineactions to correct for the errors, such as reconfiguring the motionsystem of the printer or modifying the toolpath or model correspondingto the object. If the image data is processed further when populatingthe table 1200, then the descriptor field of an entry 1205 may includefurther information regarding correction of the error, which can be usedto guide the corrective actions. This information may include aprediction regarding whether the error is repeatable, a tag grouping theerror with other errors (e.g., by similar location or error type),and/or an indication of the type of remedial action to correct for theerror (e.g., modifying the tool path, modifying the material depositionrate).

FIG. 13 is a block diagram of a system 1300 for detecting and correctingfor errors that may be implemented in a 3D printer. In particular, thesystem 1300 may be implemented in a 3D printer such as the printersdescribed above with reference to FIGS. 1-5, and may incorporatefeatures described above with reference to FIGS. 6A-12B. The system 1300may include a control system 1318, which may incorporate features of thecontrol system 118 described above. The control system 1318 controls acamera and print head assembly 600 (which may incorporate features ofthe assembly 600 described above) to print an object. The print isdefined by the object model 1320 (e.g., model 122 of FIG. 1), as well asprint parameters 1350, which can include a configuration of the printer,as well as settings specific to the object to be printed, such as amodified version of the object model 1320 (e.g., a “correction model”)or a modified tool path. During printing, the assembly 600 capturesimage data regarding the printing, which can be processed to determinedeviations 1310 from the expected print. The deviations may include, forexample, an error table 1200 as described above with reference to FIGS.12A-B. Based on those deviations 1310, the control system 1318 canmodify the print parameters 1350 to correct for those deviations duringprinting of a successive object and/or successive portions of the sameobject.

FIG. 14 is a flow diagram of a process 1400 of scanning a printed objectand calibrating print parameters based on the scan. The process 1400 maybe carried out by a printer and associated control system such as theprinter 100 and control system 118 described above with reference toFIG. 1, and may incorporate the system 1300 of FIG. 13, as well as thefeatures described above with reference to FIGS. 6A-13. With referenceto FIGS. 13 and 11A, a control system 1318 may control the assembly 600to initiate printing of an object based on an object model 1320 andprint parameters 1350 (1405). Concurrently with the printing, theassembly 600 captures images of the printed line 682 along the tool path661 (1410). Those images may be processed, for example by deriving thecoordinates and bounds of the printed line 682, and the relevant imagedate may be compared against the expected printed line according to theobject model 1320 and/or the tool path 661 (1415). If the comparisonreveals any errors from the expected printed line (e.g., deviation 675),those errors may be identified (1420).

Following completion of printing the object (1425), the image data maybe further processed to compile the errors and determine furtherinformation about the errors (1430). For example, the errors may beprocessed and described above with reference to FIGS. 12A-B, and entries(e.g., entry 1205) may be created for each error and compiled into atable (e.g., table 1200). Optionally, the errors may be filtered bycomparison against threshold parameters (e.g., extent or severity of theerror) to disregard errors for which corrective action should not betaken (e.g., non-repeatable or insubstantial errors) (1435).

Once the errors are filtered and processed, the control system 1318 maydetermine updates to the print parameters to correct and/or compensatefor the errors (1440). Those updates may include updates to theconfiguration (e.g., firmware) of the printer, such as a reconfigurationof the motion system of the printer, a change to the material depositionflow rate output by the assembly 600, an offset plane, or othermodifications as described above. The updates may also includemodifications specific to the object to be printed, such as thegeneration of (or update to) a correction model or correction toolpath.The correction model may be based on the initial object model 1320 thatdefines the geometry of the object to be printed, but includes offsetsor other modifications to the geometry to correct or compensate for theerrors. Likewise, a correction toolpath may provide instructions forcontrolling movement and deposition of the print head of the assembly600 during the printing of each layer. The correction toolpath may beimplemented for a particular segment (e.g., a given layer) of the objectto be printed.

The process 1400 may be implemented as an iterative process forcontinually improving the printing of objects through a series ofsuccessive prints. In particular, following the update to the printparameters (1440), the process 1400 may be repeated once or more for theprinting of successive objects, where the print parameters are updatedover a plurality of cycles to further improve the fidelity of theprinted object. Further, when the process 1400 is repeated, theoperation of filtering errors (1435) may account for error data inprevious cycles, which can aid in the determination of whether adetected error is repeatable.

FIG. 15 is a flow diagram of a process 1500 of modifying printparameters for an object undergoing a print based on a simultaneous scanof the object. The process 1500 may be carried out by a printer andassociated control system such as the printer 100 and control system 118described above with reference to FIG. 1, and may incorporate the system1300 of FIG. 13, as well as the features described above with referenceto FIGS. 6A-13. Further, the process 1500 may be comparable to theprocess 1400 described above, with further application to improve theprinting of an object based on a concurrent scan of the same object.

With reference to FIGS. 13 and 11A, a control system 1318 may controlthe assembly 600 to initiate printing of an object based on an objectmodel 1320 and print parameters 1350 (1505). Concurrently with theprinting, the assembly 600 captures images of the printed line 682 alongthe tool path 661 (1510). Those images may be processed, for example byderiving the coordinates and bounds of the printed line 682, and therelevant image date may be compared against the expected printed lineaccording to the object model 1320 and/or the tool path 661 (1515). Ifthe comparison reveals any errors from the expected printed line (e.g.,deviation 675), those errors may be identified (1520).

Prior to completion of the printing, the image data gathered for a firstportion of the print may be further processed to compile the errors anddetermine further information about the errors (1530). For example, theerrors may be processed and described above with reference to FIGS.12A-B, and entries (e.g., entry 1205) may be created for each error andcompiled into a table (e.g., table 1200). Optionally, the errors may befiltered by comparison against threshold parameters (e.g., extent orseverity of the error) to disregard errors for which corrective actionshould not be taken (e.g., non-repeatable or insubstantial errors)(1535).

Once the errors are filtered and processed, the control system 1318 maydetermine updates to the print parameters to correct and/or compensatefor the errors (1540). Those updates may include updates to theconfiguration (e.g., firmware) of the printer, and/or updates specificto the object being printed, as described above with reference to FIG.14. The control system 1318 may then continue printing the object underthe updated print parameters, thereby improving the fidelity of asuccessive portion of the printed object. The process 1500 may beimplemented as an iterative process for continually improving theprinting of the object. In particular, the process 1500 may be repeatedcontinuously or periodically as a given object is being printed untilthe print is complete, and the print parameters are updated over aplurality of cycles to further improve the fidelity of the printedobject. Further, when the process 1500 is repeated, the operation offiltering errors (1535) may account for error data in previous cycles,which can aid in the determination of whether a detected error isrepeatable.

The above systems, devices, methods, processes, and the like may berealized in hardware, software, or any combination of these suitable fora particular application. The hardware may include a general-purposecomputer and/or dedicated computing device. This includes realization inone or more microprocessors, microcontrollers, embeddedmicrocontrollers, programmable digital signal processors or otherprogrammable devices or processing circuitry, along with internal and/orexternal memory. This may also, or instead, include one or moreapplication specific integrated circuits, programmable gate arrays,programmable array logic components, or any other device or devices thatmay be configured to process electronic signals. Further, a realizationof the processes or devices described above may includecomputer-executable code created using a structured programming languagesuch as C, an object oriented programming language such as C++, or anyother high-level or low-level programming language (including assemblylanguages, hardware description languages, and database programminglanguages and technologies) that may be stored, compiled or interpretedto run on one of the above devices, as well as heterogeneouscombinations of processors, processor architectures, or combinations ofdifferent hardware and software. In another aspect, the methods may beembodied in systems that perform the steps thereof, and may bedistributed across devices in a number of ways. At the same time,processing may be distributed across devices such as the various systemsdescribed above, or all of the functionality may be integrated into adedicated, standalone device or other hardware. In another aspect, meansfor performing the steps associated with the processes described abovemay include any of the hardware and/or software described above.

Embodiments described herein may include computer program productscomprising computer-executable code or computer-usable code that, whenexecuting on one or more computing devices, performs any and/or all ofthe steps thereof. The code may be stored in a non-transitory fashion ina computer memory, which may be a memory from which the program executes(such as random access memory associated with a processor), or a storagedevice such as a disk drive, flash memory or any other optical,electromagnetic, magnetic, infrared or other device or combination ofdevices. In another aspect, any of the systems and methods describedabove may be embodied in any suitable transmission or propagation mediumcarrying computer-executable code and/or any inputs or outputs fromsame.

While this invention has been particularly shown and described withreferences to example embodiments thereof, it will be understood bythose skilled in the art that various changes in form and details may bemade therein without departing from the scope of the inventionencompassed by the appended claims.

1. A method for additive manufacturing of three-dimensional metalobjects, the method comprising: printing a plurality of layers to forman object on a print surface, wherein the plurality of layers areprinted layer-by-layer; scanning each of the plurality of layers toobtain scan data for each of the plurality of layers; generating a mapbased on the scan data of each of the plurality of layers; determiningwhether one or more defects exist based on the map; changing a printconfiguration if it is determined that the one or more defects exist;and printing a subsequent object using the changed print configuration.2. The method according to claim 23, wherein changing the printconfiguration includes changing at least one of a toolpath of a printhead of a printer or a flow rate of a build material deposited by theprint head.
 3. The method according to claim 23, wherein determiningwhether one or more defects of the printed object exist includescomparing a model of the object with the map of the printed object. 4.The method according to claim 25, further comprising modifying ageometry of the model of the object if the one or more defects exist. 5.The method according to claim 23, wherein determining whether one ormore defects of the printed object exist includes comparing the scandata for each of the plurality of layers in the map to eachcorresponding layer of a model of the object.
 6. The method according toclaim 23, further comprising generating print parameters defininggeometry of the printed object with offsets to a model of the object. 7.The method according to claim 23, wherein the one or more defectsinclude a discrepancy between a tool path of a print head used to printthe object and the printed object.
 8. A method of printing an object,comprising: printing a first object at a 3D printer based on an initialmodel of an object; scanning a plurality of layers of the first objectconcurrently with the printing to generate image data of the firstobject; detecting deviations between the image data and the initialmodel; updating print parameters of the object based on an initial modelof the object and the image data, the print parameters defining printedgeometry of the object with modifications to the initial model based onthe detected deviations; and printing a second object based on the printparameters.
 9. The method of claim 8, wherein the scanning includescapturing at least one photograph of the object via a camera coupled toa printer head.
 10. The method of claim 9, wherein the at least onephotograph includes a plurality of photographs, and further comprisingstitching together the plurality of photographs to generate the image ofthe object.
 11. The method of claim 10, further comprising: moving thecamera and printer head through a plurality of distinct locations abovethe build plate; and capturing each of the plurality of photographs at arespective one of the plurality of locations.
 12. The method of claim 8,wherein the scanning includes capturing photographs of a plurality ofcross-sectional layers of the first object concurrently with theprinting of the first object, the image data incorporating thephotographs.
 13. The method of claim 12, wherein updating the printparameters includes modifying the geometry of a representation of theobject based on deviations between the initial model and the photographsof the plurality of cross-sectional layers of the first object.
 14. Themethod of claim 8, wherein updating the print parameters includesgenerating a correction tool path for a print head based on the detecteddeviations.
 15. The method of claim 14, wherein printing the secondobject includes controlling the print head to print the second objectbased on the correction tool path.
 16. The method of claim 14, whereinprinting the second object includes controlling material deposition flowrate based on the correction tool path.
 17. The method of claim 14,wherein printing the first object includes: printing an initial portionof the first object according to an initial tool path; and printing asuccessive portion of the first object according to the correction toolpath.
 18. The method of claim 8, wherein updating print parametersincludes generating a correction model of the object, the correctionmodel defining the printed geometry of the object with modifications tothe initial model based on the detected deviations.
 19. A system forprinting objects, comprising: a build chamber; a printer head configuredto print objects within the build chamber; a camera mounted to theprinter head and configured to capture images within the build chamber;and a controller configured to 1) control the camera to scan a pluralityof layers of a first object concurrently with printing of the firstobject to generate image data of the first object, 2) detectingdeviations between the image data and an initial model of the object,and 3) update print parameters of the object based on an initial modelof the object and the image data, the print parameters defining printedgeometry of the object with modifications to the initial model based onthe detected deviations.
 20. The system of claim 19, wherein the scanincludes capturing at least one photograph of the object via the camera.